An interesting talk in the Radio 4 programme ‘All in the Mind’ alerted me to the Dyslexia Research Trust’s sponsorship of a garden at the Chelsea Flower Show about the impact of coloured filters on reading problems. (Thanks to @sutmae on Twitter for the nudge to the programme.)
Professor of Neuroscience at Oxford University, John Stein, and garden designer Tim Fowler, discuss the theory that colours can help with the processing of words on a page. The premise is seen as controversial by those who focus exclusively on language impairment and consequent problems with processing sounds within words so characteristic of many learners with dyslexia. Phonological processing ability is clearly a central difficulty, but to my mind it is not necessarily the only underlying cause of reading difficulties. Differences in dyslexic brains show that auditory processing is not the only indicator of dyslexia.
Stein maintains that blue and yellow backgrounds are particularly advantageous for learners with visual stress and thus the designer of the garden has chosen these colours to work with. The garden features books, first closed then open, to demonstrate that judicious use of colour (overlays, glasses) enables many youngsters with difficulties to read.
The first part of the garden contains white and green flowers. Along the path are random letters, set higgledy-piggledy in the path. This represents the problems that many learners with dyslexia have with ordering letters, especially when against white backgrounds.
You pass by a pile of closed stone books to see a mass of yellow and blue flowers surrounding a path embedded with real words. Yellow and blue are especially significant for supporting learners with specific reading difficulties.
The yellow flowers represent the filter that enables readers with visual difficulties to make the letters stay still so that they can be ordered. The visual magnocellular system is impaired in dyslexics: filters make a real difference to their experience of looking at print.
Stein says (in another talk here ):
Sometimes giving these yellow filters has a really dramatic effect, whereby a child who has been complaining that the words and letters have been moving around or are blurred can find things much clearer with yellow filters. On average, children who benefit from yellow filters will improve their reading by six months in a three month time period, therefore doubling their reading progress. This should be considered in the context that if such children are given no help to their vision then they tend to go backwards (in three months they might only progress one month). Therefore dyslexia overlays can have a significant impact.
Blue filters regulate the body clock:
It is believed that these work in a different way because the blue filters stimulate a kind of cell in the retina that is important for controlling daily rhythms. These are useful because the magnocellular system is actually favoured by yellow light. Therefore, when blue filters are given children are helped to synchronize their body clocks.
The children who benefit from blue often have problems with sleeping. Blue spectacles will improve sleeping patterns and they will be able to sleep at the right time and wake up at the right time. There is another benefit in that these same children often get migraines or stomach aches. You give them the blue glasses and these go as well because they all depend upon this hypothalamic clock.
Stein’s research provides evidence that 50% of serious reading problems can be helped by the use of blue or yellow filters.
At the end of the garden is an open and enticing book demonstrating that reading is possible. Finally a water feature – a lens shaped bowl – symbolises the importance of calm and tranquility and the reduction of stress (whether visual or emotional) that is so often a feature of learning when reading disabled.
I’d love to visit. (And I so wish there were a more dyslexia friendly WordPress theme!)


May 29, 2010 @ 10:43:16
What a beautiful quote as a title.
I’m only going to talk about my own reading experience, but it certainly works for me. I’m prone to ‘word-jumping’ when I read. It’s awkward and irritating because I only spot the mistakes when the syntax falls apart. It also means that I have to re-read at least three or four sentences on every page – I love books, but am slow. It’s a frustration.
When working on my own writing I always use a coloured background. It takes the strain out of it all and means I can read more easily and avoid tiredness. My stories benefit because I’m more able to flow.
I noticed recently, Hilery, that you’d sent me reports on blue-backgrounds and think that is excellend – it helped me a lot. To those who don’t know, the coloured background is not printed out, it is just as though it was in black and white.
Surely this is where technology provides benefit. I don’t have an e-reader, but guess it must have coloured fonts and backgrounds.
It’s also frustrating to think that we generally still go with black and white for worksheets (even moreso in these financially tight times) and that the interactive boards are often very dim in daylight and this must impede a number of children in every class.
Anyway, you’ve given me a reminder that you should be using overlays more with the children I work with – thanks for that.
nigel
May 29, 2010 @ 10:46:06
the point about my reading, which i completely forgot, is that an overlay helps considerably with word jumping. the problem has always been making sure i remember where the overlay is (usually tucked into a book that I dipped into and forgot about).